Выборы самого лучшего дума из всех думов: часть четвертая, Doom or be doomed Options

[Tular]

Doom or be doomed - не мной придуманный тезис, но он работает. Арсений тому подтверждение. Сам не верил, наверное. Но рок жесток и неумолим.

И те, кто подумал, что судьбы удастся избежать, а голосовалка увязнет в топи времён, с ужасом осознают горечь своих заблуждений и вдыхают могильных воздух.

63 гимна в саундтреке увядания.

40 Watt Sun - Carry Me Home
40 Watt Sun - Restless
Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath
Black Sabbath - War Pigs
Candlemass - Samarithan
Candlemass - Solitude
Cathedral - Hopkins (The Witchfinder General)
Cathedral - Reaching Happiness, Touching Pain
Electric Wizard - Funeralopolis
Electric Wizard - We Hate You
Ereb Altor - Awakening
Ereb Altor - By Honour
Isole - Autumn Leaves
Isole - Demon Green
Memento Mori - Heathendom
Memento Mori - I Am
Memento Mori - To Travel Within
Om - Flight of the Eagle
Om - State of Non-Return
Reverend Bizarre - Burn in Hell!
Reverend Bizarre - Cirith Ungol
Reverend Bizarre - Doom over the World
Saint Vitus - Born Too Late
Saint Vitus - Dark World
Saint Vitus - Dying Inside
Scald - In the Open Sea
Scald - Night Sky
Solitude Aeturnus - Mirror Of Sorrow
Solitude Aeturnus - Opaque Divinity
Solstice - Only The Strong
Solstice - The Man Who Lost The Sun
While Heaven Wept - Thus With a Kiss I Die
While Heaven Wept - Voice In The Wind

Anathema - A Dying Wish
Anathema - Sleepless
Doom:VS - Earthless
Doom:VS - White Coffins
Esoteric - Dissident
Esoteric - The Blood of the Eyes
Evoken - In Pestilence, Burning
Evoken - In Solitary Ruin
Katatonia - Velvet Thorns (Of Drynwhyl)
Katatonia - Without God
Lake Of Tears - Raven Land
Lake Of Tears - The Path Of The Gods (Upon The Highest Mountain, Part 2)
Mournful Congregation - The Book of Kings
Mournful Congregation - The Monad Of Creation
My Dying Bride - The Crown of Sympathy
My Dying Bride - Your River
Officium Triste - The Silent Witness
Officium Triste - Your Heaven, My Underworld
Pantheist - Be Here
Pantheist - Unknown Land
Paradise Lost - As I Die
Paradise Lost - Gothic
Saturnus - Christ Goodbye
Saturnus - I Long
Shape Of Despair - ...To Live For My Death
Shape Of Despair - Angels Of Distress
Skepticism - The Everdarkgreen
Skepticism - The Raven and the Backward Funeral
Tiamat - In A Dream
Tiamat - Whatever That Hurts

Тому, кто выживет после прослушивания такого массива дума, задача: для трада и экстрима назвать максимум по 14 песен. В каждой ветке из этих четырнадцати можно выделить максимум 7 песен в качестве фаворитов - они получат по полтора балла, остальные по одному. Если ничто не отмечено, у всех засчитывается по единице. Предполагается список располовинить к следующему туру.

статистика трад

40 Watt Sun
The Inside Room
Restless 13
Open My Eyes 4
Between Times 4
Carry Me Home 8
This Alone 0

Black Sabbath
Paranoid
War Pigs 33
Paranoid 6
Planet Caravan 0
Iron Man 12
Electric Funeral 11
Hand Of Doom 11
Rat Salad 0
Fairies Wear Boots 6
Black Sabbath
Black Sabbath 37
The Wizard 0
Behind the Wall of Sleep 0
N.I.B. 8
Evil Woman 0
Sleeping Village 0
Warning 1
Wicked World 0
Бонусы
Into The Void 4
Too Late 4
Sweet Leaf 4
Lord Of This World 2
Under The Sun 4
God Is Dead 9

Candlemass
Epicus Doomicus Metallicus
Solitude 36
Demon's Gate 4
Crystal Ball 14
Black Stone Wielder 0
Under the Oak 7
A Sorcerer's Pledge 10
Nightfall
Gothic Stone 0
The Well of Souls 13
Codex Gigas 0
At the Gallows End 13
Samarithan 20
Marche Funebre 0
Dark Are the Veils of Death 2
Mourners Lament 2
Bewitched 6
Black Candles 0
Бонусы
Ancient Dreams 4
Waterwitch 4
Dancing in the Temple (of the Mad Queen Bee) 4
Psalms For The Dead 2
The Edge Of Heaven 4
Of Stars And Smoke 8
A Tale Of creation 7
A Cry From The Crypt 2

Cathedral
Forest Of Equilibrium
Picture of Beauty & Innocence (Intro) / Commiserating the Celebration 7
Ebony Tears 8
Serpent Eve 2
Soul Sacrifice 8
A Funeral Request 4
Equilibrium 11
Reaching Happiness, Touching Pain 17
The Carnival Bizarre
Vampire Sun 9
Hopkins (The Witchfinder General) 18
Utopian Blaster 6
Night Of The Seagulls 7
Carnival Bizarre 4
Inertias Cave 0
Fangalactic Supergoria 0
Blue Light 0
Palace Of Fallen Majesty 0
Electric Grave 7
Бонусы
Kaleidoscope Of Desire 4
Frozen Rapture 4
The Voyage Of The Homeless Sapien 3

Electric Wizard 
Dopethrone
Vinum Sabbathi 0
Funeralopolis 23
Weird Tales: Electric Frost/Golgotha/Altar Of Melektaus 3
Barbarian 0
I, The Witchfinder 6
The Hills Have Eyes 4
We Hate You 14
Dopethrone 4
Mind Transferral (Bonus Track) 3
Come My Fanatics…
Return Trip 4
Wizard in Black 10
Doom-Mantia 7
Ivixor B / Phase Inducer 0
Son of Nothing 3
Solarian 13 2
Бонусы
Black Mass 4
Supercoven 4
Witchcult Today 4

Ereb Altor 
By Honour
Perennial 0
Awakening 14
By Honour 15
Winter Wonderland 0
Dark Nymph 4
Wizard 3
Ereb Altor 4
The End
The Entering (Myrding Prologue) 0
Myrding 13
Our Failure 0
A New But Past Day 4
Balder's Fall (the End Part I) 0
Vargavinter (The End Part II) 0
The Final War (The End Part III) 0

Isole 
Throne Of Void
Autumn Leaves 14
Dreams 0
Demon Green 12
Throne Of Void 3
Insomnia 0
Bleak 4
Life? 0
Bliss Of Solitude
By Blood 8
From Clouded Sky 2
Imprisoned In Sorrow 4
Bliss Of Solitude 4
Aska 0
Dying 0
Shadowstone 2
Бонусы
Forlorn 3
The Beyond 4

Memento Mori 
Life, Death And Other Morbid Tales
To Travel Within 9
The Passage… 0
A Passenger On Psycho's Path 3
I Am 6
Misery Song 0
Just Another Morbid Tune 0
My Secret Garden 4
Crown Of Thorns 1
Heathendom 6
La Danse Macabre
Endlessly 3
Lost Words 3
Crown of Thorns (Parts II, III & IV) 0
La Danse Macabre 1
Morpheus (My Deadly Friend) 3
The Loser's Trail 2
Prelude 0
The Beggar's Waltz 0
Бонус
The Things You See (And The Things You Don't) 1

Om
Conference Of The Birds
At Giza 13
Flight Of The Eagle 15
Advaitic Songs
Addis 0
State of Non-Return 24
Gethsemane 0
Sinai 0
Haqq al-Yaqin 3
Бонусы
Rays Of The Sun 4
Bhima's Theme 4
Unitive Knowledge Of The Godhead 3

Reverend Bizarre 
II: Crush the Insects
Doom Over The World 11
The Devil Rides Out 0
Cromwell 3
Slave Of Satan 1
Council Of Ten 2
By This Axe I Rule! 3
Eternal Forest 8
Fucking Wizard 1
In the Rectory of the Bizarre Reverend
Burn in Hell! 11
In The Rectory 4
The Hour of Death 1
Sodoma Sunrise 0
Doomsower 0
Cirith Ungol 11
Бонусы
Dunkelheit (Burzum Cover) 4
Anywhere Out Of This World 6
The Goddess Of Doom 8

Saint Vitus
Born Too Late
Born Too Late 12
Clear Windowpane 0
Dying Inside 6
H.A.A.G. 0
The Lost Feeling 0
The War Starter 0
Thirsty And Miserable 0
Look Behind You 0
The End Of the End 0
Die Healing
Dark World 6
One Mind 1
Let the End Begin 0
Trail Of Pestilence 0
Sloth 4
Return Of the Zombie 0
In the Asylum 2
Just Another Notch 3
Бонусы
Fear 4
Angry Man 3

Scald 
Will Of Gods Is A Great Power
Night Sky 20
Sepulchral Bonfire 7
A Tumulus 6
In The Open Sea 13
Eternal Stone 11
Ragnaradi Eve 8
Bilrost 0
Sepulchral Bonfire (Version '95) (bonus track) 0

Solitude Aeturnus 
Into the Depths of Sorrow
Dawn Of Antiquity (A Return To Despair) 0
Opaque Divinity 15
Transcending Sentinels 6
Dream Of Immortality 0
Destiny Falls To Ruin 12
White Ship 0
Mirror Of Sorrow 23
Where Angels Dare To Tread 7
Beyond the Crimson Horizon
Seeds Of The Desolate 7
Black Castle 5
The Final Sin 0
It Came Upon One Night 4
The Hourglass 0
Beneath The Fading Sun 1
Plague Of Procreation 0
Beyond... 0
City Of Armageddon 0
Бонусы
Waiting For The Light 4
Embrace 4
Tomorrows Dead 1
Falling 4
Pain 9

Solstice
Lamentations
Lamentations IV 0
Neither Time nor Tide 7
Only the Strong 12
Absolution Extremis 0
These Forever Bleak Paths 0
Empty Lies the Oaken Throne 0
Last Wish 3
Wintermoon Rapture 0
The Man Who Lost the Sun 13
Ragnorok 0
New Dark Age
The New Dark Age/The Sleeping Tyrant 0
Cimmerian Codex 4
Alchemiculte 3
Hammer of Damnation 4
The Anguine Rose 0
Blackthorne 0
The Keep 0
Cromlech 1
New Dark Age II/Legion XIII 3

While Heaven Wept 
Of Empires Forlorn
The Drowning Years 3
Of Empires Forlorn 5
Voice In The Wind 7
Soulsadness 4
Epistle No. 81 (Candlemass cover) 0
Sorrow Of The Angels 4
In Aeternum 1
From Empires To Oceans 0
Vast Oceans Lachrymose
The Furthest Shore 1
To Wander The Void 4
Living Sepulchre 1
Vessel 3
Vast Oceans Lachrymose 3
Epilogue 0
Бонусы
Into The Wells Of Sorrow 3
Hour Of Reprisal 1
Destroyer Of Solace 4
Thus With A Kiss I Die 8

статистика экстрим

Anathema 
The Silent Enigma
Restless Oblivion 19
Shroud of Frost 15
...Alone 0
Sunset of the Age 13
Nocturnal Emission 0
Cerulean Twilight 0
The Silent Enigma 8
A Dying Wish 27
Black Orchid 0
Serenades
Lovelorn Rhapsody 14
Sweet Tears 4
J'ai fait une promesse 0
They (Will Always) Die 5
Sleepless 27
Sleep in Sanity 0
Scars of the Old Stream 2
Under a Veil (Of Black Lace) 4
Where Shadows Dance 0
Dreaming: The Romance 0
Бонусы
Lost Control 3
Angelica 8
Suicide Veil 3
Crestfallen 8
Kingdom 2

Doom:VS
Earthless
Earthless 23
A Quietly Forming Collapse 7
White Coffins 12
The Dead Swan of the Woods 9
Oceans of Despair 3
The Slow Ascent 10
Dead Words Speak
Half Light 6
Dead Words Speak 6
The Lachymal Sleep 0
Upon The Cataract 0
Leaden Winged Burden 4
Threnode 7
Бонусы
The Light That Would Fade 4
Oblivion Upon Us 11

Esoteric 
Metamorphogenesis
Dissident 23
The Secret of The Secret 19
Psychotropic Transgression 4
Subconscious Dissolution into the Continuum
Morphia 4
The Blood of the Eyes 30
Grey Day 9
Arcane Dissolution 0
Бонусы
Abandonment 4
Non Being 4
Cipher 4
Enslavers Of The Insecure 4
Dominion Of Slaves 3
Beneath This Face 4
Creation (Through Destruction) 4

Evoken 
Quietus
In Pestilence, Burning 14
Withering Indignation 2
Tending The Dire Hatred 7
Where Ghosts Fall Silent 10
Quietus 4
Embrace The Emptiness 9
Atrementous Journey (Outro) 3
Antithesis of Light
Intro 0
In Solitary Ruin 24
Accursed Premonition 8
The Mournful Refusal 0
Pafor Nocturnus 10
Antithesis Of Light 4
The Last Of Vitality 0
Бонусы
Mare Erythraeum 4
To Sleep Eternally 4
The Pleistocene Epoch 4
Lost Kingdom of Darkness 4
Descent into Chaotic Dream 2
In Graven Image 4
Ascend Into the Maelstrom 3
Tragedy Eternal 4
Suffer a Martyr's Trial (Procession at Dusk) 4
An Extrinstic Divide 4

Katatonia 
Brave Murder Day
Brave 19
Murder 6
Day 4
Rainroom 17
12 13
Endtime 4
Dance Of December Souls
Seven Dreaming Souls 0
Gateways of Bereavement 12
In Silence Enshrined 14
Without God 25
Elohim Meth 0
Velvet Thorns (of Drynwhyl) 20
Tomb of Insomnia 8
Dancing December 0
Бонусы
Palace Of Frost 2
Funeral Wedding 4

Lake of Tears 
Headstones
A Foreign Road 0
Raven Land 42
Dreamdemons 11
Sweetwater 25
Life's But A Dream 0
Headstones 2
Twilight 4
Burn Fire Burn 0
The Path Of The Gods (Upon The Highest Mountain, Part 2) 31
Greater Art
Under The Crescent  6
Eyes Of The Sky  0
Upon The Highest Mountain  6
As Daylight Yields  0
Greater Art  0
Evil Inside  0
Netherworld  0
Tears 0

Mournful Congregation 
The Monad of Creation
Mother - Water, The Great Sea Wept 6
As I Drown In Loveless Rain 7
When The Weeping Dawn Beheld Its Mortal Thirst 5
The Monad Of Creation 22
The Book of Kings
The Catechism of Depression 8
The Waterless Streams 12
The Bitter Veils of Solemnity 0
The Book of Kings 15
Бонусы
Suicide Choir 6
Concrescence Of The Sophia 4
Opal of the Stream Beneath the Hills 4
A Slow March To The Burial 4
An Epic Dream of Desire 4
Fading Light Of A Dying Sun 4

My Dying Bride 
Turn Loose The Swans
Sear Me MCMXCIII 4
Your River 31
The Songless Bird 9
The Snow In My Hands 7
The Crown Of Sympathy 29
Turn Loose The Swans 15
Black God 3
The Angel and the Dark River
The Cry Of Mankind 11
From Darkest Skies 10
Black Voyage 3
A Sea To Suffer In 10
Two Winters Only 6
Your Shameful Heaven 7
Бонусы
For You 4
The Return Of The Beautiful 1
It Will Come 3
Simfonare Infernus Et Spera Empirium 8
My Body, A Funeral 3
Into The Lake Of Ghosts 1
The Sexuality of Bereavement 4
The Prize of Beauty 4
I Am The Bloody Earth 4
The Night He Died 2
Sear Me 11
Sear me III 2
She Is The Dark 4

Officium Triste 
Mors Viri
Your Fall From Grace 8
Burning All Boats And Bridges 6
Your Heaven, My Underworld 14
Interludium 0
To The Gallows 5
The Wounded And The Dying 9
One With The Sea (Part II) 0
Like Atlas 11
Reason
In Pouring Rain 12
The Silent Witness 18
This Inner Twist 8
The Sun Doesn't Shine Anymore 4
A Flower in Decay 0
Бонусы
Inside The Mind 2
On The Crossroads Of Souls 3
Roses On My Grave 4

Pantheist 
Pantheist 
One of These Funerals 4
Broken Statue 5
The Storm 4
Be Here 31
4:59 4
Brighter Days 3
Live Through Me 4
Journey Through Lands Unknown
Deliverance 4
Unknown Land 9
Dum Spiro Despero 8
Haven 0
Oblivion 8
The Loss Of Innocence 7
Eternal Sorrow 8
Mourning The Passing Of Certainty 0
Бонусы
Lust 4
O, Solitude 4
Apologeia 1
Curse The Morning Light 4
Envy 8
Don't Mourn 4
Wrath 4

Paradise Lost 
Gothic
Gothic 36
Dead Emotion 0
Shattered 16
Rapture 0
Eternal 14
Falling Forever 5
Angel Tears 3
Silent 0
The Painless 14
Desolate 0
Shades Of God
Mortals Watch The Day  14
Crying For Eternity  1
Embraced  4
Daylight Torn  1
Pity The Sadness  12
No Forgiveness  1
Your Hand In Mine  1
The Word Made Flesh  0
As I Die  35
Бонусы
Christendom 6
Forever Failure 4
True Belief 4
Embers Fire 4
Rotting Misery 3
Cry Out 4
Sweetness 3
Terminal 4
Widow 2
Flesh From Bone 4

Saturnus 
Paradise Belongs To You
Paradise Belongs To You 25
Christ Goodbye 43
As We Dance The Paths Of Fire And Solace 0
Pilgrimage Of Sorrow 11
The Fall Of Nakkiel (Nakkiel Has Fallen) 0
Astral Dawn 3
I Love Thee 6
The Underworld 0
Lament For This Treacherous World 0
Veronika Decides To Die
I Long 28
Pretend 13
Descending 16
Rain Wash Me 15
All Alone 2
Embraced By Darkness 0
To the Dreams 5
Murky Waters  15
Бонусы
Litany Of Rain 12
Softly On The Path You Fade 8

Shape of Despair 
Angels Of Distress
Fallen 15
Angels Of Distress 28
Quiet These Paintings Are 12
...To Live For My Death... 18
Night's Dew 8
Shades Of…
...In The Mist 15
Woundheir 7
Down Into The Stream 10
Shadowed Dreams 0
Sylvan-Night 6
Бонусы
Illusion's Play 4
Reaching The Innermost 8
Entwined In Misery 4
Still-Motion 4
Curse Life 2
Descending Inner Night 2
Sleeping Murder 8

Skepticism 
Farmakon
The Raven And The Backward Funeral 21
Shred Of Light, Pinch Of Endless 9
Farmakon Process 10
(Untitled) 3
Nowhere 8
Nothing 6
Stormcrowfleet
Sign Of A Storm 14
Pouring 9
By Silent Wings 4
The Rising Of The Flames 8
The Gallant Crow 9
The Everdarkgreen 15
Бонусы
The March And The Stream 12
The Organium 4
March October 11

Tiamat 
Clouds
In a Dream 42
Clouds 0
Smell of Incense 4
A Caress of Stars 22
The Sleeping Beauty 26
Forever Burning Flames 0
The Scapegoat 5
Undressed 22
Wildhoney
Wildhoney 0
Whatever That Hurts 40
The Ar 11
25th Floor 0
Gaia 0
Visionaire 16
Kaleidoscope 0
Do You Dream of Me? 0
Planets 0
A Pocket Size Sun 0
Бонусы
Via Dolorosa 4
Mountain of doom 10

Здесь можно скачать архив с экстримом: https://yadi.sk/d/EsFixHAmk2uVN
А здесь трад: https://yadi.sk/d/gni0oe_ek39yj

[Old Vyaine]

Походу, нет.

Tular the Dreamcrusher

[Vastich]

Походу, нет.

Это мнение или статистика?

[Deze]

Это мнение или статистика?

В случае с Туларом это одно и то же, он же топикмастер (IMG:style_emoticons/default/1488.gif)

[Tular]

Это мнение или статистика?

Статистика. В следующий тур проходят по 15 (плюс-минус) песен из ветки. Но в траде "минус" к пятнадцати гораздо ближе, чем "плюс".

В случае с Туларом это одно и то же, он же топикмастер

I am the law and you won't fuck around no more

[Vastich]

1,5 Anathema - A Dying Wish
1,5 Anathema - Sleepless
1,5 Doom:VS - Earthless
1 Doom:VS - White Coffins
1,5 Lake Of Tears - Raven Land
1 Lake Of Tears - The Path Of The Gods (Upon The Highest Mountain, Part 2)
1 My Dying Bride - Your River
1 Pantheist - Unknown Land
1 Paradise Lost - As I Die
1,5 Saturnus - Christ Goodbye
1 Saturnus - I Long
1 Shape Of Despair - ...To Live For My Death
1,5 Tiamat - In A Dream
1,5 Tiamat - Whatever That Hurts


Ну всё, я закончил, можно ехать дальше (IMG:style_emoticons/default/dwarf-1.gif)

[Illogicist]

Katatonia - Velvet Thorns (Of Drynwhyl) 1 балл
Katatonia - Without God 1 балл
Lake Of Tears - Raven Land 1,5 балла
Lake Of Tears - The Path Of The Gods (Upon The Highest Mountain, Part 2) 1,5 балла
My Dying Bride - The Crown of Sympathy 1,5 балла
My Dying Bride - Your River 1,5 балла
Officium Triste - The Silent Witness 1 балл
Officium Triste - Your Heaven, My Underworld 1 балл
Pantheist - Be Here 1,5 балла
Pantheist - Unknown Land 1 балл
Paradise Lost - As I Die 1 балл
Paradise Lost - Gothic 1 балл
Tiamat - In A Dream 1,5 балла
Tiamat - Whatever That Hurts 1,5 балла

[Tular]

Отлично. Завтра (уже сегодня) ровно в полдень голоса прекращаю принимать.